Landlord and rental property insurance for Worthington businesses
Worthington, founded in 1803, is one of Ohio’s most charming historic towns, with a classic village green, mid-century neighborhoods and easy access to downtown Columbus. Our Columbus office is just south on Olentangy River Road.
Whether you are in Old Worthington or Colonial Hills, your landlord insurance is handled by the same local agent from quote to claim.
- DP-3 dwelling policies
- Loss of rent
- Portfolio options
- Serving Worthington (43085)
- About 10 minutes from our Columbus office

Landlord and rental property insurance near you in Worthington, Ohio
Searching for landlord insurance near me, an independent agent or a local insurance company in Worthington? Here is what to know.
Independent landlord insurance agency in Worthington
Slyman is an independent agency, so we compare landlord insurance from several top-rated companies instead of selling just one.Landlord and rental property insurance company in Worthington, Ohio
We place landlord insurance with top-rated insurance companies and handle your service and claims locally in Worthington.Landlord and rental property insurance near me
About 10 minutes from our Columbus office. Our Columbus office is at 4701 Olentangy River Rd, Suite 102, Columbus, OH 43214. Call 614-475-3583.Landlord and rental property insurance agent in Worthington
A licensed local agent who knows Worthington explains your landlord insurance options in plain language.Cheap landlord insurance in Worthington
Affordable landlord insurance comes from comparing carriers and stacking discounts: bundle several rentals, updated roofs and systems, higher deductibles.Best landlord insurance in Worthington
The best policy is the one with the right coverage and a local agent at claim time. Clients rate us 5.0 on Google.Landlord and rental property insurance quotes in Worthington
Get free landlord insurance quotes online or by phone, usually within one business day.Landlord and rental property insurance cost in Worthington
Cost depends on your ZIP code (43085), coverage, limits, deductibles and history. We show prices side by side.What landlord insurance covers in Worthington
The main protections in a landlord insurance policy. Your agent helps you choose limits and options.
What affects landlord insurance in Worthington
Local conditions in Franklin County shape the coverage we recommend.
Main routes in Worthington
- US-23 (High Street)
- SR-161 (Dublin-Granville Road)
- I-270
- SR-315
- Wilson Bridge Road
Where we serve
- Old Worthington
- Colonial Hills
- Rush Creek Village
- Worthington Estates
- Sutton Place
Who needs landlord insurance in Worthington?
Single-family rental ownersOne or a few homes.
Duplex and triplex ownersIncluding owner-occupied.
Apartment building ownersCommercial habitational coverage.
Short-term rental hostsSpecial coverage needed.
Investors with portfoliosBlanket or schedule policies.
Student housing landlordsCampus-area rentals.
Rental property in Ohio
Worthington has a large rental market, from campus housing near Ohio State to suburban single-family rentals. Each needs a landlord policy rather than a homeowners policy.
Ohio landlords have duties under the state landlord-tenant law, and liability claims from tenants and guests are common. Tenants should carry their own renters insurance for their belongings.
- Require tenants to carry renters insurance.
- Older rentals may need ordinance or law coverage.
- Short-term rentals often need special policies.
Dwelling policy forms
| Form | Covers | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| DP-1 | Named perils, actual cash value | Older or lower-value rentals |
| DP-2 | Broader named perils | Moderate coverage |
| DP-3 | Open perils on the dwelling, replacement cost | Most rentals |
| Commercial habitational | Larger buildings | Apartment complexes |
Getting landlord insurance in Worthington, step by step
List properties
Address, units, age and updates.
Choose a form
DP-3 for most.
Set rent loss limits
Months of rent.
Add liability
Or an umbrella over all rentals.
Require renters insurance
For tenant belongings.
Why Worthington businesses choose Slyman
Your local agents for Worthington
4701 Olentangy River Rd, Suite 102, Columbus, OH 43214
About 10 minutes from our Columbus office. Mon–Fri, 9:00 AM to 4:30 PM.


